E-mails and comments welcome from teachers and learners of all ages.  
July 21, 2003
How useful are exams?

Alice Bachini on exams:

I'm so glad I'm not a teacher anymore

Partly because you have to deal with things like exam grades being completely stupid and meaningless. How does a teacher spend all year encouraging kids to take something seriously, only so that at the end of the year, the whole thing ends up becoming a farce?

Well, in my view, almost all school exams are pretty farcical. They don't help children learn, and there's no real value whatever in examining them on things unless they need clearly to demonstrate some kind of commitment to and ability in some subject in order for universities to have confidence in accepting them on courses, say.

If people are going to have examinations, they should organise them properly, with some kind of decent academic standards. At least then people know where they stand. Otherwise, they definitely ought to forget the whole thing.

I'm not so sure. Proving commitment is right, but it's not just proving it to universities.

In Brian-world, children decide for themselves whether they take exams or not, but if they want my advice I'll tell them that exams surely prove something important besides the mere matter of whether they have merely learned the contents of the syllabus. They prove, it seems to me, the ability to handle information under pressure, on the one big occasion when it really matters. This is surely an immensely important skill, and arguably the key skill of working in a modern information-based economy.

It is said that, a few years later, and maybe even a few weeks later, you will have forgotten everything you "learned" for those exams you took. So what? Most of us forget the facts around whatever task we are performing, after we have performed it.

I will have forgotten most of the mere facts surrounding this post pretty soon, and probably in a matter of a few days. That's not the point. The point is: Am I using the knowledge I now have to make a worthwhile point, to you, now? If I am, then mission accomplished, and if I've forgotten all about it in a week, that won't matter. The posting will still be here, in the archives, even if I have to think hard to remember anything about it myself.

What exams test is the habit of switching on one's concentration, onto what matters, when it matters. And since concentration can't be permanently switched on, exams also test the ability to switch off one's concentration at the right times, and thereby to make best possible use of it.

This is why employers take exam results seriously, and why they are surely right to do this.

It is also surely why they are not that bothered about the mere content of the syllabuses being examined. Just so long as it's something, and just so long as the brains of the examinees were really tested.

Posted by Brian Micklethwait at 10:58 PM
Category: Examinations and qualifications
[0]
Comments

We also need exams to make sure that the educrats who run the schools are giving the kids a proper curriculum. There are way too many teachers out there who'd be perfectly content not to test at all, and to spend the entire day on "creative" [read: frivolous] pursuits that waste time in school and produce high school graduates who can't string two sentences together or add simple sums.

I know that's a little harsh, but I'm not talking about all teachers...but it's true of a significant minority. And when dubious educational ideas like constructivism in math or whole-language instruction in reading take hold in whole districts, look out below. You'd better have an exam in place that at least ensures that students have the basic skills necessary to move on to their next level or grade.

Comment by: J.P. Laurier on July 22, 2003 01:58 PM

Dear All

I seem to be having trouble uploading new stuff here. I don't know exactly why this is, although I have some theories.

Anyway, I'm now going to try to upload this comment.

Comment by: Brian Micklethwait on July 22, 2003 03:27 PM

Well that seemed to work.

Odd.

Presumably comments and uploading are quite different systems, and use different bits of the internet, or whatever. Ergo, uploading can be interrupted, while commenting can continue unabated. But what do I know?

Maybe I should be made to take and exam.

Comment by: Brian Micklethwait on July 22, 2003 03:28 PM

And now I seem to be back in full business again.

I tried a slightly different way of doing things, and it worked.

You have just witnessed me handling information under pressure.

Comment by: Brian Micklethwait on July 22, 2003 03:33 PM

To me, a large advantage of exams, (apart from winning me scholarships and letting me skip the first year of university and other nice material advantages) was that they actually forced me to sit down and learn something difficult. Which is something I am terribly bad at making myself do without any such incentive.

Comment by: Tracy on July 24, 2003 06:35 AM

Exams are not the problem. What bothers me is the fluctuation of grade boundaries. Why not set the grade boundaries in stone (A*= >90%, A= >80* and so forth), this way, you know what to aim for and it's fairer. I hate, hate, hate (triple hate, that's big hate) the fluctuating grade boundaries. One year 62% is a C and the next it's a D or a B even. Not logical.

Comment by: K on July 31, 2003 07:04 PM

Incest porn incest stories. Mother incest free incest stories. Insest stories incest pics. Incest stories free incest pictures. Cartoon incest incest sex. Incest pics incest porn. Incest xxx free incest pics. Simpsons incest family incest. Gay incest stories gay incest twin incest. Free incest galleries incest sex stories. Incest grrl free incest pictures. Free incest pic incest cartoons incest drawings. Free incest pic father daughter incest. Incest tgp mother son incest incest forums. Pictures incest incest videos. Incest comics incest story. Free incest pics free incest sex stories. Incest forum brother sister incest. Free incest pictures incest movies. Incest videos incest photos amateur incest. Incest pic incest taboo incest toons. Family incest lesbian incest. Free incest pics mom son incest incest family. Father son incest incest stories free. Incest mom son erotic incest stories. Mother and son incest young incest incest video. Incest forums free incest movies incest story. True incest stories mother daughter incest granny incest. Incest art incest gallery. Gay incest stories teen incest. Incest erotic stories incest forum. Lesbian incest incest grrl. Incest taboo forum incest forums incest porn. Family incest stories incest tgp. Incest porno incest taboo forum. Incest board incest rape actual incest. Brother sister incest incest comics. Gay incest cartoon incest. Incest xxx free incest porn. Incest drawings incest quest. Incest sex pics incest family. Young incest incest galleries. Free incest movies incest pic. Incest forums mother and son incest. Gay family incest free incest videos. Free incest pics free erotic incest stories actual incest. Incest quest incest sites russian incest. Free incest porn real incest incest stories free. Incest quest stories of incest incest pics. Incest grrl mature incest. http://rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-pictures.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-videos.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasy.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://gay-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://gang-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-video.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-porn.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-movies.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-sex.pictures-archive.com/ http://fantasy-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://anal-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://fantasy-rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://teen-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-photos.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasy-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-pictures.pictures-archive.com/ http://gang-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://lesbian-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://teen-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://real-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://hentai-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://incest-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://anime-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://asian-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://family-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-comics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-sites.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-victims.pictures-archive.com/ http://how-to-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://tentacle-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://prison-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://male-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://bondage-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-movies.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-websites-with-screams.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-story.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-videos.pictures-archive.com/ http://cartoon-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://workplace-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://sex-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasies.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-fantasy.pictures-archive.com/

Comment by: mother son incest on January 11, 2005 12:21 PM

Incest porn incest stories. Mother incest free incest stories. Insest stories incest pics. Incest stories free incest pictures. Cartoon incest incest sex. Incest pics incest porn. Incest xxx free incest pics. Simpsons incest family incest. Gay incest stories gay incest twin incest. Free incest galleries incest sex stories. Incest grrl free incest pictures. Free incest pic incest cartoons incest drawings. Free incest pic father daughter incest. Incest tgp mother son incest incest forums. Pictures incest incest videos. Incest comics incest story. Free incest pics free incest sex stories. Incest forum brother sister incest. Free incest pictures incest movies. Incest videos incest photos amateur incest. Incest pic incest taboo incest toons. Family incest lesbian incest. Free incest pics mom son incest incest family. Father son incest incest stories free. Incest mom son erotic incest stories. Mother and son incest young incest incest video. Incest forums free incest movies incest story. True incest stories mother daughter incest granny incest. Incest art incest gallery. Gay incest stories teen incest. Incest erotic stories incest forum. Lesbian incest incest grrl. Incest taboo forum incest forums incest porn. Family incest stories incest tgp. Incest porno incest taboo forum. Incest board incest rape actual incest. Brother sister incest incest comics. Gay incest cartoon incest. Incest xxx free incest porn. Incest drawings incest quest. Incest sex pics incest family. Young incest incest galleries. Free incest movies incest pic. Incest forums mother and son incest. Gay family incest free incest videos. Free incest pics free erotic incest stories actual incest. Incest quest incest sites russian incest. Free incest porn real incest incest stories free. Incest quest stories of incest incest pics. Incest grrl mature incest. http://rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-pictures.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-videos.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasy.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://gay-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://gang-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-video.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-porn.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-movies.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-sex.pictures-archive.com/ http://fantasy-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://anal-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://fantasy-rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://teen-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-photos.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasy-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-pictures.pictures-archive.com/ http://gang-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://lesbian-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://teen-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://real-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://hentai-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://incest-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://anime-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://asian-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://family-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-comics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-sites.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-victims.pictures-archive.com/ http://how-to-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://tentacle-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://prison-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://male-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://bondage-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-movies.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-websites-with-screams.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-story.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-videos.pictures-archive.com/ http://cartoon-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://workplace-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://sex-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasies.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-fantasy.pictures-archive.com/

Comment by: mother son incest on January 11, 2005 12:21 PM

Incest porn incest stories. Mother incest free incest stories. Insest stories incest pics. Incest stories free incest pictures. Cartoon incest incest sex. Incest pics incest porn. Incest xxx free incest pics. Simpsons incest family incest. Gay incest stories gay incest twin incest. Free incest galleries incest sex stories. Incest grrl free incest pictures. Free incest pic incest cartoons incest drawings. Free incest pic father daughter incest. Incest tgp mother son incest incest forums. Pictures incest incest videos. Incest comics incest story. Free incest pics free incest sex stories. Incest forum brother sister incest. Free incest pictures incest movies. Incest videos incest photos amateur incest. Incest pic incest taboo incest toons. Family incest lesbian incest. Free incest pics mom son incest incest family. Father son incest incest stories free. Incest mom son erotic incest stories. Mother and son incest young incest incest video. Incest forums free incest movies incest story. True incest stories mother daughter incest granny incest. Incest art incest gallery. Gay incest stories teen incest. Incest erotic stories incest forum. Lesbian incest incest grrl. Incest taboo forum incest forums incest porn. Family incest stories incest tgp. Incest porno incest taboo forum. Incest board incest rape actual incest. Brother sister incest incest comics. Gay incest cartoon incest. Incest xxx free incest porn. Incest drawings incest quest. Incest sex pics incest family. Young incest incest galleries. Free incest movies incest pic. Incest forums mother and son incest. Gay family incest free incest videos. Free incest pics free erotic incest stories actual incest. Incest quest incest sites russian incest. Free incest porn real incest incest stories free. Incest quest stories of incest incest pics. Incest grrl mature incest. http://rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-pictures.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-videos.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasy.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://gay-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://gang-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-video.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-porn.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-movies.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-sex.pictures-archive.com/ http://fantasy-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://anal-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://fantasy-rape-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://teen-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-photos.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasy-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-pictures.pictures-archive.com/ http://gang-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://lesbian-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://teen-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-pics.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-stories.pictures-archive.com/ http://real-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://hentai-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://incest-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://anime-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://asian-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://family-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-comics.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-sites.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-victims.pictures-archive.com/ http://how-to-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://tentacle-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://prison-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://male-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://bondage-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-movies.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-websites-with-screams.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-story.pictures-archive.com/ http://free-rape-videos.pictures-archive.com/ http://cartoon-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://workplace-violence.pictures-archive.com/ http://sex-rape.pictures-archive.com/ http://rape-fantasies.pictures-archive.com/ http://forced-sex-fantasy.pictures-archive.com/

Comment by: mother son incest on January 11, 2005 12:21 PM
Post a comment





    







    •